Tag: angel investors

  • The Hidden Structure of an Investable Startup

    The Hidden Structure of an Investable Startup

    As they develop their companies, founders must give consideration to the metric of investability.  It’s a metric that is challenging to apply because the yardstick of measurement is human judgment. Judgment is complex, and we can understand it like other complex phenomena by breaking it down into parts and understanding how those parts relate to each other.

    About ten years ago, Jamie Rhodes and I had the opportunity to combine his understanding of investment with my proficiency with modeling.  Jamie is a tremendous resource for understanding this topic, as he is the founder of the Central Texas Angel Network and the Alliance of Texas Angel Networks, and a serial entrepreneur (check out his exciting company Sio-Tex ). The result is a blueprint that founders can follow to design for investability, and that they can use to revise their companies when investment doesn’t occur.

    Startup Investor's Hierarchy of Needs

    The blueprint is arranged as a hierarchy, inspired by Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs.  At the outset, Jamie and I brainstormed a number of parameters that were important to consider when making an investment decision.  It turned out that while all were important, they could be ordered from more fundamental to less fundamental.  Deficiencies in more fundamental levels makes the opportunity easier for an investor to dismiss.  Less fundamental deficiencies are more apt to be addressable, and it’s here where a hands-on investor begins to see where they could add value.

    Like any blueprint, it’s not a picture of a process, but of an outcome.  It’s not chronological or developmental.  Founders are free to design, redesign, develop, and build any part at any time.

    Motivation

    The most important consideration for an investor is the motivation of the founders.  After many years in school, people can be motivated to get paid rather than make money – it’s what public schooling was originally designed for – supplying the labor market.  Founders need to be interested in obtaining returns from markets, not with getting rewarded by some authority for being innovative, working on a problem, or being right.  The right motivation is evident when founders describe a compelling vision, and care enough about generating revenue to make it grow.  It’s absent when founders want to be rewarded solely for their commitment to changing the world, or when they want to prove a point, or where the vision is banal.

    Team

    Companies are made out of people, and savvy investors know this.  In my experience, nearly every failing startup’s problems can be traced to team dysfunction. Again, the public school system was designed to recognize and reward individual merit, and so the virtuous ability to work with others is more rare than it might be. 

    We can further break down how teams work, in order to create another blueprint – I’ll cover that in more depth in a future article and replace this with a hyperlink.  Teams work when the members are collaborative, and when three fundamental roles are addressed, with nothing neglected and with no overlap in responsibility that will create conflicts.

    The roles concern themselves with answering questions: What is possible?  What is needed?  What can be delivered? What the company does is negotiated among the people answering these question.

    Teams must also have an ability to communicate both internally and externally – a networking capacity – that means they can work among themselves and also work collaboratively with mentors, advisors, investors, and customers. None of us is as smart as all of us.

    Market Engagement

    Investors want to know about the dialog between the founders and the markets.  Markets are vast, oceanic, and ultimately mysterious, but we want our founders to have done more than stand on the shore or ride in a glass-bottomed boat.  Market engagement means our founders have gotten wet.  Like divers who have cut turtles loose from fishing nets, or removed fishhooks from the mouths of sharks, we want to hear real and moving stories of engagement and problem-solving.

    Product (Not Just Technology)

    “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.” – Mike Tyson

    Most technologists struggle with the placement of this element in the model.  To them, it seems obvious that a tech startup’s foundation is technology.  While these individuals may succeed at getting grant funding, investors have different criteria than grantmakers (although that difference is shrinking), and a lack of discernment here means a lack of investment.

    It’s worth noting that technologies never enter markets – only products.  Investors want to see that the technology has been productized through collaboration with customers.  An easy way to see that this hasn’t happened is when founders pitch the many possibilities of their platform technology.  Discerning investors will see in this the unmanaged risk of creating a viable product.

    Position (Not Just IP)

    Investors want to see intellectual property rights strategy, but this is not as simple as just checking the “patent pending” box.  What they more fundamentally want is to see a positioning strategy: how the company will establish and protect a position in the marketplace. Certainly, obtaining patent rights is a way to position your company on the innovation landscape, but more importantly founders need to be able to explain why this opportunity is their opportunity and no one else’s. 

    Patent rights are a negative right, a right to exclude others.  They are analogous to real estate property rights, the right to prevent trespass.  Other ways to keep the competition off of your turf include but are not limited to: establishing exclusive supply arrangements or exclusive distribution agreements; establishing joint development relationships; building in-house know-how that is hard to replicate or reverse engineer; maintaining trade secrets; and controlling source code.

    Convincing Yourself, Convincing Others

    Once you internalize this blueprint, you can use it as an investor to refine and guide your inquiry.  As a founder, you can use it to think like an investor yourself – and you owe it to yourself to do this, since just by being a founder you are investing things in your company that are far more precious.  And as a founder, this blueprint can help you understand feedback from an investor and have a better dialog that could lead to making changes that will make your company better.

    I often ask founders, how do you know if your company is any good?  Many will point to the quality of their technology, their business plan, or the importance of the problem they are solving.  But really, it’s not enough for founders to decide their company is good.

    If you are fundraising, you are in the market for investment.  The bottom line answer to whether your company is any good is that the market will agree with you; no amount of convincing yourself will take the place of also convincing others.  You have to agree, and this blueprint will help you do that.

  • Universities and Angels

    Schuerman: Today’s topic is University-Angel Investor relations, and I’m fortunate to be talking with exactly the right person for that topic, Mr. Jamie Rhodes. Jamie is the founder of the Central Texas Angel Network, which provides funding and support to Texas entrepreneurs across a broad spectrum of industries. He created the Alliance of Texas Angel Networks, which represents over 300 investors. He is vice-chair of the board of directors of the Angel Capital Association, a national organization spun out of the Kauffman Foundation representing seed stage investors. I say that Jamie is exactly the right person because in addition to all of this, he served as The Texas A&M University System’s Director of New Ventures and has experience in looking at things from the university perspective.

    Before we begin, Jamie, I wanted to share with our readers the fact that angel investment in Texas is seeing some exciting new developments – could you comment on this?

    Rhodes: In Texas we have focused on growing our angel investing ecosystem for the last seven years and it is paying off. The Halo report on angel investing for 2013 shows that two of Texas’ angel groups are in the top four most active angel groups in the country, as ranked by number of investments.

    Schuerman: I’ve embedded the report above, and queued up slide 14 that shows the Houston Angel Network and Central Texas Angel Network rankings that you’re talking about. There really does seem to be a new ecosystem since I came to Texas back in 2001 – angels seemed few and far between and most of the VCs I knew were not local. In any case, well done and thanks for everything you are doing to support entrepreneurs.

    That brings us to the topic of entrepreneurial effort of universities and their goals in forming start-up companies, as well as how they can best work with angel investors to get discoveries out of the lab and into the marketplace through new company formation. It’s always a good idea to understand the motivations of someone you want to work with, so let me ask first of all – what motivates a typical angel investor?

    Rhodes: The typical motivation for an angel is to invest in a team that can grow a company in three to five years to an exit. Notice that I said team, and not technology. The challenge for a university is that most of their opportunities, because they are very early stage, are more like six to eight years from an exit, and the team is generally not in place yet. So universities don’t have typical opportunities and should not be looking for angels who are motivated in a typical way.

    Schuerman: So working with a university is not for every angel investor.

    Rhodes: Exactly. Universities need to connect with angels who have an interest in a scientific field and who are interested in getting to know researchers and evaluating them. Angel investors generally assess entrepreneurs, but university start-ups or university opportunities are, in most cases, not far enough along to have attracted an entrepreneur. So an angel working with a university needs to be applying the same due diligence process they would use with an entrepreneur to the researcher and anyone else from the university that will be on the early-stage team.

    Schuerman: In what other ways would such an angel investor be different?

    Rhodes: They’ll be on the board of directors, and the rule of thumb for board members is “nose in, hands out.” But that doesn’t work for university start-ups – in this case, angels need to get their hands dirty.

    Schuerman: It sounds like the ideal angel is someone who is also a bit entrepreneurial themselves.

    Rhodes: Yes. If an angel approaches opportunities like an entrepreneur – doing some market research, brainstorming about the possibilities – that is a very good sign. If the angel is focused on the transactional aspect of the opportunity – licensing the patent – that suggests that they are not thinking about making an investment.

    Schuerman: So what would they be thinking about in that case?

    Rhodes: They may be benchmarking – trying to get a sense of how your technology compares to technologies they have in one of their companies, or how they might complement them. Benchmarking is a legitimate activity, but as a university you need to recognize it and take the opportunity to expand the relationship.

    Schuerman: It’s like having a shop, and having someone come in just to browse and kill some time – it’s an opportunity to engage them and make a sale.

    Rhodes: That’s right.

    Schuerman: Good advice. Okay, so let’s talk about experience. How important is it for an angel investor to have invested in university start-ups before? Or to have invested in similar companies before? Or to have invested in any company before?

    Rhodes: Let’s take those one at a time. First of all, I would say it’s highly desirable for the angel to have worked with a university before. If they haven’t, it’s crucial that the university tech transfer office (TTO) get involved, because there are some pitfalls for an unexperienced angel.

    Schuerman: Such as?

    Rhodes: Researchers may not clearly understand or explain complexities about intellectual property rights. It may be that their IP rights are constrained by a sponsored research agreement, or even by an existing license agreement. IP rights may be spread across two or more institutions due to collaborative technology development. They may talk about technology as patented when it is patent-pending.

    Schuerman: I have seen examples of all of those. Another problem is that a researcher may want to start a company, but then continue to use the licensed technology in their own research enterprise and engage commercial customers, effectively creating a competitive situation between their lab and the start-up.

    Rhodes: These situations are unique to universities, and that’s why an angel who has never worked with a university needs some help from the TTO to recognize and either avoid or manage these problems.

    Schuerman: Okay, so how important is experience in investing in similar companies?

    Rhodes: For university opportunities, there is far more technology risk, and so domain experience is crucial.

    Schuerman: I agree. I have seen people retire from the energy sector and decide to helm a university biotech start-up. They have no domain expertise, and so they have no idea what they are getting themselves into – and no way to get themselves out of it. I can easily see that the problem for an investor without domain expertise would be the same.

    Rhodes: You also asked about first-time angels working with a university. The blunt answer is that angel investing is tricky and first-timers are likely to fail – and are much more likely to fail when working with a university. A first-time angel working with a university would have all of the challenges of being an angel investor, compounded with the challenges of working with an early stage opportunity.

    This is where the value of an angel network lies. If an angel investor has peers who he or she can observe, learn from, and be mentored by, the risk of failure can be greatly mitigated. So if I were at a university and had an interested first-timer, I’d want them to be part of a good angel network.

    Schuerman: Most people looking for start-up investment immediately think of VCs. What criteria should I use to decide whether to approach venture capital investors vs. angels?

    Rhodes: Approach both, but recognize the differences. Angels are your best bet for funding a broad range of business opportunities as compared to VCs, and odds are that more of your opportunities will fit the angel’s investment criteria. VCs have more narrow criteria and are looking for deals that will require significant investment, but have the potential for much larger payoffs. A $30M return would be a homerun for an angel, but a failure for a VC. And with VCs, like angels, most don’t like university-stage deals. So universities need to do their homework and focus their efforts on connecting with ones that do.

    Schuerman: I’ve talked with people who get excited by the prospect of pitching to a single angel investor, but who see angel networks as potentially too complicated to deal with. What are the pros and cons of investment from a network?

    Rhodes: For universities, it’s all upside; there is power in numbers. A network means more check writers, more evaluators, and more diversity of deal funding. Since universities need to look for that special subset of angels who are right for their early-stage deals, networks are ideal for simplifying the job of finding those individuals.

    Schuerman: I’ve heard a VC complain that a start-up was “messed up” by an angel investor. Should I be concerned that taking money from the wrong angel investor can damage a start-up?

    Rhodes: VCs who claim that “angels screwed things up” are putting the blame in the wrong place. Companies get screwed up with they are mismanaged – the IP doesn’t get locked down well, equity stakeholders have come and gone without the right paperwork being done, liabilities have been created, and so on.

    Schuerman: Makes sense. If I give someone gas money and they drive their car into a ditch, it’s hardly my fault.

    Rhodes: Right. Someone can certainly blame you, but ultimately it’s whoever was behind the wheel that was responsible.

    Schuerman: Okay, very good. Let’s talk now about stage of development. How far along does my start-up need to be in order to attract angel investment (e.g. concept, beta, product launch, first customer contract)?

    Rhodes: You need a prototype or beta version. It’s possible to get investment earlier, but you’re going to be competing with other opportunities that are farther along.

    Schuerman: Let’s say, though, that I’m not at that stage. Is it reasonable to want to work with an angel to develop business concepts?

    Rhodes: It doesn’t hurt to ask, and many angels would be delighted to get involved at this point. Just note that you won’t be attracting financial investment, you’ll be attracting their attention and expertise. This is a great way to build a relationship.

    Schuerman: I’ve heard that some angels charge a fee in order to hear a pitch. Should I be concerned if an angel wants to charge me to pitch to them?

    Rhodes: For an established company to make a pitch to an angel group, this is reasonable. Pitch fees serve a gatekeeping function, so that angels don’t end up hearing from the guy who is opening a second sandwich shop, and they also pay for the due diligence that is a necessary step before investment can be made.

    Pitch fees for a university don’t make sense and I would regard them as a red flag. Universities are not generally pitching start-ups so much as they are pitching potential start-ups. However, universities can consider ways to make it more interesting to an angel group to listen to and provide feedback on opportunities. For example, a university could offer to cover a certain amount of patent expenses for any company that is formed as a result of angel investment. This type of gesture builds trust and communicates that the university is willing to be a true partner.

    Schuerman: Jamie, this has been very informative. Thank you for your perspectives and insights. Any last thoughts on best practices for universities when partnering with angel investors?

    Rhodes: Don’t wait until you need money to get to know angels. The goal is to create a trusted relationship.